Pdf limitations of balanced scorecard semantic scholar. Performance evaluation using balanced scorecard model in. The balanced scorecard as a performance management tool. This paper explores one aspect of the benchmarking program that has been developed by the brazilian electrical energy distribution companies association abradee and the committee of business management foundation funcoge at the institute of. The scorecard quantifies and summarizes important data, which facilitates cooperation between departments to resolve issues and enhance university activities. Here is a much longer list of the sectors and clients we have helped. More than 550,000 employees service the companys customers in nearly 5,000 locations spread across 14 countries in. It focuses attention of management on only a few performance measures and bridges different functional areas as it includes both financial and nonfinancial measures.
This solution provides a practical application of the principles of the balanced scorecard, within a specific business case or scenario. However, the choice of multiple case study was due to difficulties of studying deeply an insightful case applying a longitudinal method. For more details on the edf energy balanced scorecard case study you can follow the reference link. All four main areas of consideration are bound by the business organizations vision and strategy. But financial measures tell the story of past events, an. Balanced score card bsc, performance measurement, pipe industry.
The development of the balanced scorecard as a strategic. A case study though studies abound for large organizations where use of the balance scorecard is quite common, literature focusedon the uses and limitations of the balanced scorecard in small and mediumsized enterprises smes is. Balanced scorecard stepbystep volta river authority. The worldclass lighting experience case solution,making balanced scorecard work. Tesco adopted the balanced scorecard method in the mid 1990s to drive its strategy and operations. Reading the balanced scorecard ikea harvard case study. Porters five forces strategic analysis of the balanced scorecard ikea case study. First, there is a lot of evidence supporting an argument that a balanced scorecard translates a strategy into operational terms kaplan and norton, 1996. Dec 22, 2004 the balanced scorecard bsc has become a popular concept for performance measurement. The balanced scorecard concept moves stakeholders away from a singleminded obsession with traditional accounting data. This study aims to analyze and explain the adaptation of the balanced scorecard bsc, through the theoretical model by. In this case, ensuring and focusing on only one of these cues may be dangerous. Successful design and implementation requires that the process, its designers and facilitators are intelligent and flexible.
Crucially, the fiveyear scorecard was devised to meet specific performance targets to the year 1998. Balanced scorecard ikea case study solution and analysis of. It supplies 30% of the food purchases made in the uk. Initially, fast reading without taking notes and underlines should be done. Kaplan and norton describe the innovation of the balanced scorecard as follows. To have a complete understanding of the case, one should focus on case reading. Mecklenburg county, north carolina the situation mecklenburg county is the largest county in north carolina and the most urban. The balanced scorecard approach will only have results when other mechanisms such as a well functioning board and it steering committee are in place. The benefits of using balanced scorecard as a strategic management system are linked to the structure of a balanced scorecard process. The worldclass lighting experience case study solution, in 2002 worldclass lighting made the initiative to introduce a balanced scorecard in the asiapacific region and the greater china region, in. Particularly, the case study relates a balanced scorecard project implemented in 2000, in a nonprofit organisation, the boston lyric opera, an opera house company in boston.
Review this case study featuring an implementation of the balanced scorecard. Consequently, in order to realize increased revenue and profit margins, the management must first focus on achieving high customer satisfaction. Vision and strategy, the vision is the future and the gap between now and the future leads to a plan of action to achieve the vision. Pdf on jan 1, 2014, anna nagyova and others published case study of balanced scorecard use in automotive industry. Balanced scorecard bsc as information based strategic management tool is capable of removing the limitation associated with the. In this case study was balanced scorecard used in the automotive company to ensure the alignment of objectives with the o rganization strategy and to balance the indicators into fou r perspectives. Describes basic functionalities of balanced score card. Performance measurement and balanced scorecard implementation. To analyze the structure of a company and its corporate strategy, porters five forces model is used. As the results demonstrate, its balanced scorecard implementation was a great success and has been featured in case studies and shared at conferences throughout north america and beyond, and has earned the organization a spot in the balanced scorecard collaboratives hall of fame. The balanced scorecard retains traditional financial measures. It has also been discussed that in order to follow the objectives accurately, it is very important to monitor the achievement of those objectives by using as optimal and as. These survey results show that companies using the balanced scorecard are consistently benefitting from it.
Unums success with its balanced scorecard has been the result of getting a number of fundamental things right building and implementing a balanced scorecard, case study. Balanced scorecard bsc has been used in different businesses with different sizes. Successful case studies balanced scorecard institute emea. Definition and concept an approach to the provision of information to the management to assist with.
The bank of ghana ghanas central bank released an international rfp for consultancy contract for the adoption of balanced scorecard methodology in strategic planning and management. This case study primarily focuses on the recalibration of the fmoh scorecard in 20092010, the cascade work performed in 201120, and the breakthrough improvements that the ethiopian health sector achieved as a result of improved strategic direction and alignment using the institute wa y. Veolia water uses balanced scorecard to drive north. The focus will be on the balanced scorecard introduction in one case organization. Using balance scorecard in educational institutions. Balanced scorecard, example and case study free download as powerpoint presentation. Aims and indexes of balanced scorecard are determined by strategy and perspective of organization. In fact, it has been such a success that the prime. It can help to align biggerpicture goals with individual employee objectives.
Balanced scorecard is the system of management, which appeared in the 1990ies. Conceptual foundations of the balanced scorecard 3. The county, which includes the city of charlotte, has approximately. Balanced scorecard ikea case study solution and analysis. Strategic management using balanced scorecarda case study. The case study of a cooperative credit bank in piedmont, concluded that a control system is needed based on comprehensive framework that translates companys strategy into a. These aims and indexes look at performance of organization in four aspects. Norton, the balanced scorecard bsc is a revolutionary way to handle strategy management and has been one of the most popular methodologies used over the past three decades. The balanced scorecard in a pharmaceutical company. This case study demonstrates how a large fortune 100 companys manufacturing plant adapted the balanced scorecard principles implemented at its facility for use to manage and improve the overall performance level of the plants primary mro suppliers. Balanced scorecard basic free download as powerpoint presentation. Client case studies from our strategic balanced scorecard work.
A case study of pipe industry pages 14331438 download pdf. This paper is aims to apply the balanced scorecard approach in educational institutions by replicate the strategic plan of the private university case study arab academy for science. With strategy being such an element of our work, many clients do not want their case studies made public and we respect that. Indeed, some organizations focus on their key strategies to set up another. Strategic planning model formulation based on balanced score. Managers today are acting in such a complex environment that setting right objectives and following them appropriately is absolutely vital to ensure the sustainability and development of any organisation. The balanced scorecard concept, popularised by robert s kaplan and david p norton, is a performance management tool that encompasses the financial measures of an organisation.
Adapting the balanced scorecard to improve mro supplier. Nov 17, 2014 however, as is shown in this case study, the balanced scorecard is only a technique that can only be successful if the business and it work together and act upon the measurements of the scorecards. However, as is shown in this case study, the balanced scorecard is only a technique that can only be successful if the business and it work together and act upon the measurements of the scorecards. David norton and i introduced the balanced scorecard in a 1992 harvard business. Balanced scorecard example the following is an example of how one might develop a balanced scorecard. However, doubts frequently arise regarding the quality of the bscs developed as well as the quality of the process in which this development. As it is shown in figure 1, these four perspectives provide a frame for balanced scorecard. Tesco is the largest food retailer in the uk and one of the leading grocery retailers in the world. Read articles about balanced scorecard hbs working knowledge. Anytown hospital has just finished a twoday retreat where they revised and updated their mission and vision statements and drafted a strategic plan. Balanced scorecard case study 2382 words case study. Balanced scorecard for rainbow lighting ltd from the case study, rainbow lighting ltd senior management has insisted that the firm must record an 18% return on capital employed in the next two years. The balance scorecard may also be able to identify closely with managers and solve a variety of problems.
In this model, five forces have been identified which play an important part in shaping the market and industry. At the direction of auguste, the executive leaders of veolia water north america approached the balanced scorecard institute to define a strategic planning and management system based on the balanced scorecard. But in the case of hsbc, it centralizes the use of balanced scorecard in a single department. Unum corporation summary disability and special risk insurer unum corporation has used a balanced scorecard to drive the company towards its strategic vision. Bswa planned the contract execution and facilitated the set up of various crossfunctional teams to work with our team. The balance scorecard shows what matters in achieving the mission at hand and is kind of a frame work to achieving a strategy. Large firms as well as small and medium sized enterprises smes tend to use multidimensional bsc instead of relying on traditional performance measurement. What follows, provides guidance and advice on the development and implementation of a balanced scorecard for those organisations considering the introduction of a. Budgeting and the balanced scorecard a oxiteno case. The balanced scorecard bsc is an innovative management accounting tool, designed. Following is the simplest illustration of the concept of balanced scorecard. Strategic management using balanced scorecard a case study on tata power meenu chopra, vikas gupta, and bharat chhabra south asian journal of business and management cases 2017 6. Balanced scorecard case study solution case study analysis. Cal poly pr directors also use the balanced scorecard to help justify budgetary needs.
This longer webinar walks you through the mechanics of building a scorecard, surfacing the measures, linking the strategy to what people do, and establishing the right management practices. The balanced scorecard is used by both small and large organizations. The balanced scorecard in healthcare clearpoint strategy. Performance evaluation using balanced scorecard bsc and. It explains how the principle is applied and the benefits of the concept for the business in the specific case. Case study 2000 regency parkway, suite 425 cary, north carolina 27518 usa phone. The balance scorecard presents a widespread view of the factors that influence performance and growth. Siegel get budgeting basics and beyond now with oreilly online learning.
Pdf boston lyric opera balanced scorecard case study. The worldclass lighting experience case analysis, making balanced scorecard work. For more, read for more, read their article, the balanced scorecard. The aim of the system is to create more direct plans of the development and improvement of a company and ensure their realization. Nopadol rompho department of operations management, faculty of commerce and accountancy thammasat university, 2 prachan rd. Balanced scorecard in higher education applied case study on.
To study this issue we have to evaluate all the targets included in the balanced scorecard of the company, because we think that it was possible to determine if the contribution of those definitions are a significant issue to create high level of. However, in some cases, financial performance measures were apparently forgotten as managers, stock analysts and investors became obsessed with customer satisfaction and intangible asset growth. The scorecard provides concrete data to support changes to budget and explain the need for expenditures. In this case study was balanced scorecard used in the automotive company to ensure the alignment of objectives with the o rganization strategy. Balance scorecard case study solution case study analysis. Typical performance management focuses on monitoring tasks, and then managing them or taking action whenever the tasks diverge from what is expected. Abstract the balanced scorecard bsc has taken a prominent role as a reference methodology to develop research and as an internationally adopted corporate practice.
A study to analyze financial performance and management of hsbc. Balanced scorecard basics communicat business systems. Similarly, the complexity of running an organization required the managers to pay attention to the organization indicators simultaneously in some domains. Balanced scorecard, example and case study strategic. The effect of balanced scorecard on strategy participation. Linking the balanced scorecard case study solution, background of the company mobil corporation is basically one of the largest three companies in the gas, oil and petrochemical industry, with its headquarte. This case study will discuss the top lessons learned by mecklenburg county, nc during seven years of implementing and using the balanced scorecard institutes. More recently it has been proposed as the basis for a strategic management system. The latest business management research and ideas from hbs faculty. These are just a few case studies from a much wider collection of client projects.
Successful case studies balanced scorecard institute emea is the regional leader in government performance and strategy execution using the balanced scorecard as the. Notably, it centers your vision and strategy around four distinct perspectives. The balanced scorecard is a widely adopted performance management framework first described in the early 1990s. Initial reading is to get a rough idea of what information is provided for the. A case study of the balanced scorecard in public hospitals. Balanced scorecard in higher education applied case study on arab academy for science, technology and maritime transfer dr. Introduction the literature on the diffusion of managerial practices in the organizations is characterized by two ways of explaining the adaptation process, the first derived from the economic literature based on the rational actor model. Nov 21, 2008 the basic approach of the balanced scorecard case study management system is outlined for a hypothetical company. The four boxes represent the main areas of consideration under balanced scorecard. Particularly, the case study relates a balanced scorecard project implemented in 2000, in a nonprofit organisation, the boston lyric opera, an opera. The balanced scorecard framework is the most important achievement of performance measurement revolution. This longitudinal case study aims to further develop the accounting change model of cobb et al. Research balanced scorecard in indian includes research. The balanced scorecard bsc approach to performance measurement is gaining, over the last decades, an increased popularity due its strategic use of key.
1376 465 720 881 1218 1245 1015 952 363 405 337 1389 298 750 993 679 1029 561 701 723 1231 1085 1374 661 426 1393 825 1419 92 1322 116 745 1408 775 215